A Writer’s Secret Weapon- The Writing Group
I have a secret-weapon writing group. Shouldn’t you? A writing group can be the best, fastest and easiest way to get quality feedback on your work.
It’s low pressure, usually informal and completely in your control for those of us suffering from commitment-phobia. What’s the best bit? It gets you writing. You’ll only need to rock up without new material once to be inspired (read: shamed) back to your computer pulling some late nights. If you choose the right folks you’ll be so inspired that you’ll want to lose sleep over them.
My group meets twice a month in a coffee shop or bar, we bring what we’ve been working on and we critique each other’s work. Simple. To some, the idea of a writing group seems quaint or outdated; especially when you consider the social networking communities that exist all over the internet. However, my group has a fiercely powerful effect on me. They push me to be productive when I don’t want to be, nurture my small beginnings and mini-ideas, and kindly tell me when a piece is, um, bad.
How is this different in person? Well, for starters, you’re all in the same place at the same time, sharing. Not that I would advocate a rosy critique of something that needs a lot of work. However, one tends to practice humility and courtesy when you know your work will be under the microscope in ten minutes time. We’re all vulnerable, and when people are face-to-face there’s a lot less room for misunderstanding or unnecessary harshness. You’ll learn to give and receive feedback in a less emotional way and ultimately learn how to critique your own work better as a bi-product.
You don’t need to have friends in publishing to gather some smart literary people. You do, however, have to get over some fears, get organized and practice good writing group etiquette to keep your group together and be productive. Next week I will discuss tips on how to build a writing group and how to ensure that you all behave yourselves!
What is YOUR experience with a writing group?
Rachel Fachner is a writer, choreographer, and theatre director living, at the moment, in Australia. In the literary world she has worked for Jill Grinberg Literary Management and Tin House Books in addition to being a freelance editor. She runs project: transparence and builds work for Collective Dance NY.



Great article!
I tried starting my own writing group a while ago. Nobody was really into it, so I’m definitely looking forward to the next article in this series!
We do workshopping in my creative writing class but I want more! Would love to join one and skip the hassle of starting my own in a new city where I don’t know anyone…
Elena, thanks for the feedback. I know how tough it can be starting up a group, my group took a couple months to get going. If there are people who you particularly like in your class, that might be a good place to start. Stay tuned for some more tips!
This sounds like just what I need. I’ve been writing for years (still unpublished) but have never had my work critiqued.
Victor, I’m so glad this will help! Having your work critiqued can be nerve-wracking at first, but it’s a vital part of bettering your craft. Stay tuned for more!
Getting together with other writers, sharing what you’re working on, and even collaborating on new stories is what it’s all about!
There’s nothing better than talking story with another writer; they understand where you’re coming from, what you’re trying to do, and the struggle you’re facing. Writing groups are awesome for this reason.
Though I’ve never been a part of an independent writer’s group before, I have taken a lot of writing classes, which are essentially the same thing — it’s the best. For me, there’s no better place to meet with other writers than a college or library of some kind … you’re surrounded by a history of thinking, knowledge, and inspiration.
While I’m gearing up to head back to UCLA for some more writing classes, I’m also launching a new adventure online for writers interested not only in connecting with others, but creating stories as well. While it’s not exactly the place for feedback, I’m hoping it becomes a place where writers can actually contribute their creative storytelling abilities to ongoing stories of all genres. It’s in beta mode right now, but you can check it out at ScribblePlay.com
Christopher, thanks for the insightful comment! I completely agree that writers are in the right mindset for giving critique. Having a supportive group dynamic is essential for participants to feel comfortable not only sharing, but being open to new ideas. Writing classes are fantastic, I’ve participated in a couple myself. They can lend themselves well to someone who starts many projects and finishes none, as the class will eventually end and most times there is no follow through. A writing group with longevity, however, will press you onward to completion. Both have their benefits and curses. Good luck back at UCLA!