Your First Draft is Allowed to Suck!
In this article, Icy Sedgwick reminds us all that our first draft is just that, a draft, and gives us advice on how to keep that in mind and improve our writing.
If you’re anything like me, you probably spend a portion of your day keeping up with your contacts on Twitter. If you’re reading this blog, then many of your contacts are probably writers. As a result, you’ll probably see many tweets saying “Should be writing but playing Farmville” or “I’ve got too much to do to get any writing done today”. You might even be one of the tweeters saying that. There are a thousand reasons why a writer might not be writing, and that’s ok. You don’t have to write every minute of every day. However, when a writer has the time and the inclination to write but chooses not, I’d venture to guess that the writer is afraid.

Fear to the Dark Side leads
Yep, I said it. Afraid. They’re either afraid that whatever they produce will be rejected when it’s sent on its merry way into the submission system, or they’re afraid it will be so bad it won’t even make it as far as this system. If they don’t write, then they can’t inflict a work of colossal “bad-ness” on the world, and all will be well (we’ll ignore those writers who end up unleashing terrible books on the world anyway – at least they were writing!). So let me break it to you as easily as I can… if you never write, then you’ll never know how bad it is, but at the same time – you’ll never know how good it is, either!
Even the professionals start somewhere
I can’t help thinking that we’re so hung up on the books that we’ve read that we expect ours to look the same when we’re finished writing. We understand the process involved, but for some reason we assume when it comes to other writers, they give birth to fully formed novels that ooze perfection from every correctly placed semi-colon. We forget that the writer no doubt spent hours tearing out his or her hair when a scene didn’t work the way they thought it should, or that this very same book has, at some point, existed as a manuscript covered in red pen.
It’s called a first draft for a reason!
The term “first draft” implies that the manuscript you hold in your hands is not finished – hence it being a “draft”. The very fact it is called the first draft implies there are more drafts to come. This is because no one expects you to get it right straight out of the box – if they did, you wouldn’t be writing your first draft, you’d be writing a novel, and editors everywhere would change career. Your first draft is the product of your inner hyperactive toddler, the one that gets distracted by all the new things and the shiny possibilities, who leaves plot lines hanging, gets character names wrong, and decides to change narrative direction halfway through. It’s supposed to look like that.
Get involved
The first draft is supposed to be exciting! Anything can happen – and frequently does! Humanity is a species that excels at making mistakes and then learning from them. So get stuck in, make some mistakes, and just run with the story. You can always go back (well, should go back) and fix things later. It’s ok if you write plotlines you never finish or switch allegiances between characters – no one need ever know, because you’ll smooth all these rough edges when you write your second draft.
It happens to all of us
Take it from someone who knows. I’m in the process of finishing a first draft for a novella and it’s a mess. It changes from third person past tense to first person present tense halfway through, there are currently no chapter breaks, and I’m sure one of my characters changed their name. My protagonist waited until I was almost finished to point out that he would like a different career – the one he suggested works better within the narrative, so I’m ending the book with my guy following his new career, meaning I need to edit the first three-quarters of work where he’s doing something else. There are plenty of other changes I’d like to make, but these are the main ones. Am I bothered? No – because this is just the first draft. I’ll go back and make my changes in the second draft.

Now, write!
Remember the cardinal rule of writing – you can’t edit a blank page. That blank page is just a piece of paper – whereas a first draft is raw material that can be honed. Michelangelo didn’t go to the quarry and find David embedded in the rock – he had to coax the statue out of the marble. Your first draft is that hunk of marble, and it’s only once you’ve written it that you’ll get to start chipping away to find the art inside. So go get your hunk of marble, and see what you can produce!
Images courtesy of Graham Binns and Dark Botxy.


Rewriting is where the real writing begins. Good blog. Thanks.
Excellent post!
Procrastination is my enemy. Fear leads to my procrastination.
I overanalyze, overthink, and get nothing done. My pages remain blank.
I’m too afraid to fail, or maybe too afraid to succeed.
Or maybe I’m too afraid to let down the perfect ideas in my head, afraid they will become imperfect by putting them on paper.
—-
A writer writes.
A painter paints.
A sculptor sculpts.
A dog-walker walks dogs.
They take action. They do.
So what about someone who does not… write?
Great intel. I’m going to get some tattooed on my chest.
Practice. Practice. That’s what it’s all about.
Thanks for the wealth of information. For me, editing seems to be the most fun. Everything is already in place. All I have to do is move things around, and perfect them.
Terrific post, Icy. First drafts are for getting the bones of the story put down. Rewriting is where the magic is, filling it out and getting it ready for polishing into a gem. You’re on target about fear. Fear leads to the loss of many a good book, I think.
Take care,
Jess
Your blog came just in time, after yet another rejection for a simple article and feeling I have lost my mojo. The more I worry, the more the voice in my head quietens. I was going to give up and look for a
J O B.
Fear is holding me back and trying to do too many things at once. I wanted to be a novelist but have strayed into ebooks, blogs, and articles and then wonder why I can’t think what to write in my novels anymore.
Thank you for an excellant blog,
Best wishes in all your writing,
Lesley
Fear can be such a debilitating thing when it need not be.
This is a wonderful post. While I knew the majority of what you wrote I have still been suffering from the doubts and pangs of fear perhaps subconsciously, perhaps not. More than anything it is nice to know that other writers suffer from the same doubts. Thanks for that.
Some people write unnaturally, some edit even more unnaturally. Sometimes it’s harder for a writer to run with a second draft, but maybe that’s because he doesn’t know how to run well at all. If we were all less fearful, we’d all be better off – or at least get more done. Or is it laziness instead of fear, or is laziness only a cover-up for fear? Me, I’m encouraged by how many great writers worked only because they were hungry. I may be only a few hours away, daily for a year, from creating my own greatest work.
Another great post – thanks for passing this along!
Ah, the fear of not being afraid. I’ll get there soon. Thanks for this!
I just discovered your blog and am overwhelmed (in a good way) about how much great and helpful content is here.
I agree about the importance of writing a crappy first draft. I just discussesd this concept (which I learned from Anne Lamott’s Bird by Bird) in my blog: http://missgoodonpaper.blogspot.com/.
Thanks for sharing; I can’t wait to read more! =)
Great post! I wrote one similar but I was less nice than you o.0 I say not only is the first draft allowed to suck, but 90% of it will suck! It’s supposed to. Word vomit is fabulous but there is a reason most authors show their first drafts to NO ONE!
Thanks for the encouragement!!
It’s difficult to actually abide by this, it’s always so easy to think “No, I want to edit”, but resist the urge and keep going!
Excellent article. My blog writing flows more naturally than my fiction writing. I suppose that’s because I’m thinking in my voice when I blog. When I’m writing my fictional characters I think I overwrite them for fear that my characters won’t be understood in the same way I see them. That fear definitely keeps me from making progress. Thank you for the great post. It’s encouraging! :)
There are times when I can hear my Inner Editor as she screams. It is sometimes difficult to write with all that racket, but I warned her at the beginning of November, if she couldn’t stay out of my way as I worked on this novel I would have to put her in the broom closet.
She’s not happy, and will most likely pull the first draft apart at the seams.
For now, however, I am able to write 1,000 words an hour (when I can get my butt into gear) without editing a single word of the deliciously error-filled crap that is my first draft of ‘I Killed Them, Mama’.
That’s the thing – we think our Inner Editor is going to be helpful but in essence, they become a hindrance. She can have a go when you’re finished!